We’re here when you need us most.

Select an insurance product to start a quote

Bundle & Save up to 23%

Auto

Home

Renters

Life

Business

Farm and Crop

Insurance Product

Please select a product.

Damaged car with a large red object smashed through the windshield, parked in front of a house, with two people observing the scene

Account Shortcuts

Your Insurance at a glance.

Meet Your New Family

Our team strives to provide you with the best quality coverage in the state of Indiana. There are no games here. We plan on supplying you with the information you need to understand what type of coverage is best for the value. Let’s talk about how we can customize a policy that fits your needs and your budget.

Michael
Carey

Agency Owner

arrow_forward_ios

Chad
Pryor

Agency Producer

arrow_forward_ios

Amber
Campbell

Agency Associate

arrow_forward_ios

Products

An agency that provides trust and reliability.

Our agency was built on determination and a passion to serve our neighbors. Indiana is our home; that’s why it is so important to us to protect those who live here. We offer auto, renters, home, life, business and farm insurance and can help to create policies that are designed for your current stage of life. Let’s go on this journey together and trust the Carey Agency to take care of your insurance needs. Contact us or request a quote online to start protecting you and your loved ones today.

Auto

Home

Renters

Life

Business

Farm

Family car trip preparation to go for a vacation

Auto

Take to the open road covered and confident, no matter what you drive.

EXPLORE AUTO COVERAGES

Home

We've got options to help you keep the home you love covered.

PROTECT YOUR HOME

Renters

Feel confident with your coverage from move-in to move-out.

Happenings

Company sweepstakes, office drawings, job listings and more! Let us know what you are interested in below and you could be one lucky winner.

Refer a Friend

You can receive up to a $25 gift card when you refer a friend to the Carey Agency.

I’m Interested
Discounts

Interested in saving? Learn more about our discounts.

I’m Interested
My Member Deals

Your Indiana Farm Bureau membership gives you access to more than 289,000 offers and discounts.

I’m Interested
We are Hiring

Interested in joining our family? We offer job opportunities for all talents.

I’m Interested

New

Get a Quote

First Name

First Name is required.

Last Name

Last Name is required.

ZIP Code

Enter a valid ZIP code.

Preferred Contact Method

Choose a contact method.

Email Address

Enter a valid email address.

Phone Number

Enter a valid phone number.

Message

Your message was sent.

Reach Out

Carey Agency Boonville

Mailing Address

location_on 225 S Second St., Boonville, IN 47601-

Office Hours

schedule

Mon-Fri 10:00AM - 4:00PM

Phone Number

smartphone 812-897-0598

Carey Agency

Mailing Address

location_on 3101 N Green River Rd Ste 610, Evansville, IN 47715-1375

Office Hours

schedule

Mon-Fri 8:30AM - 5:00PM

Phone Number

smartphone 812-901-7700

We’re here when you need us most.

Get a cheaper rate by bundling
your insurance Get a cheaper rate by bundling
Home + Auto insurance Get a cheaper rate by bundling
Renters + Auto insurance

Select an insurance product to start a quote

Your Insurance at a glance.