Inside
Story

 

by Indiana Farm Bureau Insurance

 

 

 

 

teenage girl bucking seat belt
flowrist picking flower from garden
men grilling food and smiling
indiana farm bureau insurance agent with desk
Nov 18, 2026

What is subrogation, and how might it affect your claim?

Understanding subrogation and what it may mean for your claim

Imagine this scenario: Someone rear-ends you at a stoplight. Your car is damaged, you file a claim with your insurance company and they pay to fix it. You’re back on the road, and the claim is closed. But there’s typically more to the story. Your insurance company is now likely working behind the scenes to recover the money it paid from the person believed to be responsible for the accident. This process is known as subrogation. 

 

What is subrogation?

 

Subrogation is the process by which your insurance company seeks to recover the money it paid on your claim from the person (or that person’s insurance company) who was determined to be responsible for causing the accident. Your insurance company may also be attempting to recover the deductible you may have paid during the claims process. 

 

Think of it this way: You pay premiums to your insurance company to help protect you if unexpected events occur. If someone else causes the damage, it’s not fair for you or other policyholders to bear the financial burden. For that reason, an insurance company may pursue the party responsible to recoup the costs. 

 

An important thing to know upfront

 

It’s important to understand that getting your deductible back is not guaranteed, and the process can take a significant amount of time. 

 

While this may be frustrating, especially if you’ve paid a substantial deductible, knowing this upfront can help you manage expectations. 

 

Why do insurance companies pursue subrogation?

 

You might wonder why your insurance company goes through the process of subrogation if it’s not guaranteed and often takes a long time. Here are some of the key reasons: 

  • Accountability: Can help ensure that the party responsible for the damage pays for it, rather than you or other policyholders. 

  • Potential deductible recovery: Although not guaranteed, successful subrogation may result in the full or partial reimbursement of your deductible. 

 

What can influence if I get my deductible back?  

 

Your insurance company will often pursue deductible recovery as a courtesy, but several factors can influence the outcome: 

  • Shared fault: If you’re found to share some blame for the accident, you may receive only a portion of your deductible back. 

  • Unclear fault: If it’s difficult to determine who was responsible, recovery can become complicated. 

  • No insurance or limited coverage: The responsible party may have no insurance or insufficient coverage, making recovery impossible. 

  • Disputed responsibility: The responsible party may contest the claim, which can lead to lengthy negotiations or legal action. 

 

You typically have the right to pursue your deductible recovery independently by contacting the other party or their insurance company directly.  

 

How long does this process typically take? 

 

Subrogation can be a time-consuming process. Here’s a general timeline for illustrative purposes: 

  • Often at least 90 days: From the settlement and payment of your claim until a demand letter is sent and a response is received. 

  • Auto accidents: Often takes six months or longer to resolve. 

  • Homeowners claims: Can often take several years, and in some cases, deductibles may never be recovered. 

 

What can and can’t insurance companies typically recover?

 

It’s important to understand what your insurance company may or may not be able to recover through subrogation: 

 

Insurance companies typically can pursue: 

  • Amounts paid under your policy for vehicle repairs or property damage 

  • Medical bills paid under your medical payments coverage 

 

Insurance companies typically cannot pursue: 

  • Any of your out-of-pocket expenses (e.g., rental car costs, extra transportation, meals while displaced) 

  • Your injury claim. If you were injured, you generally need to work with the other insurance company or consider hiring an attorney to represent you. Your insurance company can only recover medical bills it paid under medical payments coverage. 

 

Questions about your rates

 

If you’re concerned about how filing a claim might affect your premiums, contact your insurance agent to learn more. 

 

Who may contact me about this process?

 

Insurance companies often hire specialized law firms to handle subrogation on their behalf. These firms are experts in negotiating with other insurance companies and pursuing legal action when appropriate. If your matter is assigned to one of them, it generally means your insurance company is working to recover money for your claim. 

 

What generally happens next? 

 

Here’s what you may expect going forward: 

  • Successful recovery: If money is recovered, you’ll typically be notified, and deductible reimbursement will be sent to you. The amount may be full or partial, depending on the recovery and the circumstances of the loss. Any funds recovered above your deductible are retained by your insurance company for amounts they paid on your claim. 

  • Unsuccessful recovery: If no money is recovered, you’ll be informed that the subrogation file was closed. While disappointing, this brings the process to an end. 

  • In the meantime: You may not hear from your insurance company for several months. This is normal, as the process typically continues behind the scenes. 

 

The bottom line

 

Subrogation aims to recover money from the party responsible for the loss, helping to ensure that you and other policyholders don’t bear the cost of someone else’s actions. 

 

It’s important to approach the subrogation process with realistic expectations: 

  • Time: It can take months or even years. 

  • Outcome: Recovery is not guaranteed. 

  • Effort: Your insurance company may work on your behalf, but they can’t control the other party’s cooperation or ability to pay. 

 

Your insurance company will make reasonable efforts to pursue recovery and keep you informed during the process. If you have any questions, please contact your claims adjuster or the subrogation team working on your matter. 

 

 

 

Inside Story is for educational and informational purposes only. Inside Story is compiled from various sources, which may or may not be affiliated with our family of companies, and may include the assistance of artificial intelligence. While we strive to provide accurate and reliable content, we make no warranties or guarantees about its completeness, accuracy, or reliability, and are not responsible for the content of any third-party sources or websites referenced herein. The inclusion of any content does not establish a business relationship or constitute our endorsement, approval, or recommendation of any third party. Testimonials and examples provided are for illustrative purposes only and do not guarantee future or similar results or outcomes, and may not consider individual circumstances, goals, needs, or objectives. Inside Story does not provide legal, tax, or accounting advice. For individual guidance, please consult a qualified professional in the appropriate field. 
Coverages subject to policy terms, conditions, and exclusions. Subject to underwriting review and approval. 

 

Indiana Farm Bureau Insurance

Your dedicated

agent awaits. 

 

Get ready to meet your go-to

for all things insurance. 

 

Bearded man enjoying an outdoor barbecue with a drink in hand, standing next to a grill on a sunny day, creating a relaxed backyard gathering vibe