| Performance Round Two | ||||
| First | Last | Title | School | |
| Lindsey | Keiser | Secrets of Life | Benton Central High School | |
| Tia | Timberlake | Secrete' | Broad Ripple High School | |
| Shalisa | Elliott | I Feel like Dying | Broad Ripple High School | |
| Ashlee | Turner | Mandala | Broad Ripple High School | |
| Jamie | Swartz | Gniraeh | Broad Ripple High School | |
| Gregory | Manning | "Within" | Broad Ripple High School | |
| Hillary | Smith | Broken Balance | Cathedral High School/Carmel High School | |
| Jenna | Rifkind | Thankful | Center Grove High School | |
| Brittany | Davis | Diary | Clarksville High School | |
| Jared | Wagner | Camp Secrets | Clay High School | |
| Nicholas | Smith | Twenty Somethin' | East Noble High School | |
| Talia | Smith | The Octopus | East Noble High School | |
| Elizabeth | Atz | Relationship Survival | East Noble High School | |
| Shelby | Wainwright | SOS | East Noble High School | |
| Nicholas | Smith | Kiss | East Noble High School | |
| Nik | Castle | Bathroom Confessions | East Noble High School | |
| Kari | Schargenberger | Secretly I hate people | Floyd Central | |
| Blake | Oliver | Survive the Day | Floyd Central | |
| Katie | Thurston | untitled | Floyd Central | |
| Audrey | Minix | Sister Secrets | Floyd Central High School | |
| Brittany | Gay | Not As It Seems | Jennings County | |
| William | Thomas | untitled | Lawrence Central | |
| Zachary | Perry | Playing Secrets | Lawrence Central | |
| Jordan | Reed | Too Much Rain | Mount Vernon High School | |
| Emily | DiNoto | The Secret of Truth | Our Lady of Providence High School | |
| Jenny | Lindsay | It Was Always There In You | Penn High School | |
| Jordan | Knecht | Secret Love | Roncalli | |
| Brooke | Brown | Behind The Wall | Roncalli High School | |
| Katherine | Ajamie | A Tough Break-up | Roncalli High School | |
| Hannah | Sego | Secrets of the Heart | Whiteland Community High School | |
| Lauren | Linder | Inflection | Yorktown High School | |